In 1967 in tamil nadu their more bonded labourers worked for landlord without no wages only for food. When 1rupee rice came many people came out from bonded labourers and ask their landlord proper wages for their work. 2) the laptop for school students. Which helps for their studies In COVID times for past two years then the tamilnadu govt itself starts won satellite education channel named kalvi channel. In which it teaches for all students from 1std to 12 std in particular time interval. 3) some media and institute will say it is freebies it is not a freebie it is a social engineering process. Upliftment of poor. All poor are paying indirect taxes. For their buying products. In the name of GST. How will you give back the money to them by directly. Not only by freebies the state becomes debt. The main reason by corruption in discom in importing of coal.
Thanks for taking up the topic. A lot of literature is coming up on this issue. The recent RBI report on the debt situation of states try & define what could be considered as a freebie or a genuine welfare measure. A recent SC judgement also advises the govt. to approach the Finance commission (only instrument coordinating between the centre & states after the erstwhile Planning commission) to simplify the situation. The article shown earlier in the IE is by N.K. Singh, the former chairman of the finance commission & is a detailed one. There is one more article published in the Hindu by Kalaiyasaran A. which presents a bit of contradictory view. Btw whenever I try & attach a link the comment doesn't get posted, Sorry for that. But, please do check the article out 🙏🙏
What is the difference between '"freebie" or revadi and "NPA or other Write offs". Only difference is freebie is petty amount to poor and down trodden and "write offs" ,to rich Corporates, who indirectly route money to political parties and politicians Of course distribution of any goods can be checked, but not "free health, free education, free drinking water" which are constitutionally mandated. Again subsidised electricity and transport to poor and down trodden should be considered a welfare act. Now who is a "Tax Payer"? Till recently an Income Tax Payer was considered as tax payer which now a days looks farce. Because GST paid by each citizen poor, down trodden, lower middile and middle which category constitute 80 to 90% of population. Even excise duty to petrol products are also lagely shared by the non rich category. Now the question do the lower category of population get their due pro rata share of GDP, means the fruits of development? A big no is the answer. So the lower segment be brought up by paying free health, education, and other subsidised services like water, electricity, transport etc. The current sudden rise of question is clearly understandable to be a BJP sponsored project to prevent Kejriwal to capture India, but will fail, by all means. Politicians and parties must realise that " Voters are Masters" not those to whom votes are cast. It is good if better sense prevail in the initial stage only.
Subsidies aren't freebies. They should not be. They are different from freebies. Subsidy could be granted to enhance welfare and production in a certain way. But, freebies are a medium to gain political support .
Thank you ma'am 😊 Subsidies, we get after spending or producing or contributing in the economy, it is a help to bear the cost, while freebies have no role in the Development.
Dear aspirant, Glad you asked the question for better enlightenment. Well, let's take a state which has a relatively lower level of development but it has a larger share of the population suffering from poverty, now in that case, such kind of freebies become need based Hence, it becomes essential to provide the people with such subsidies for their own upliftment. The freebies can serve as welfare in such states. For better and more knowledge on the topic, you can look at the article given below: www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/are-freebies-affecting-the-economic-growth-of-india/article65363024.ece Your interest and engagement with the channel is highly valued and necessary for our upcoming segments. Thank you. Regards, Team Drishti IAS.
Becoz freebies leads to rise in prices If someone is not paying the money then someone else has to If poor are not paying than middle class has to bear this burden And middle class are back bone of the country i dont think so it's good for long term see what happened to Sri Lanka becoz of freebies
There is 0% chance of recession in India( Bloomberg report) but freebie culture can change everything Please spread this message Giving jobs is better than giving free electricity,water etc
![Diggy Graves - Red Vineyard [Official Lyric Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/8Ro085T0mnQ/mqdefault.jpg)
In 1967 in tamil nadu their more bonded labourers worked for landlord without no wages only for food. When 1rupee rice came many people came out from bonded labourers and ask their landlord proper wages for their work.
2) the laptop for school students. Which helps for their studies In COVID times for past two years then the tamilnadu govt itself starts won satellite education channel named kalvi channel. In which it teaches for all students from 1std to 12 std in particular time interval.
3) some media and institute will say it is freebies it is not a freebie it is a social engineering process. Upliftment of poor.
All poor are paying indirect taxes. For their buying products. In the name of GST. How will you give back the money to them by directly.
Not only by freebies the state becomes debt. The main reason by corruption in discom in importing of coal.
Well said bro ..
One man's freebies is another man's essential social spend..
Yeah bro🙌🙌damn true.... Such a nice explanation 💥
You are right
To be honest . I heartily like your channel . In the bottom of my heart. Because the way of explanation topic is epic
Thanks for taking up the topic. A lot of literature is coming up on this issue. The recent RBI report on the debt situation of states try & define what could be considered as a freebie or a genuine welfare measure. A recent SC judgement also advises the govt. to approach the Finance commission (only instrument coordinating between the centre & states after the erstwhile Planning commission) to simplify the situation. The article shown earlier in the IE is by N.K. Singh, the former chairman of the finance commission & is a detailed one. There is one more article published in the Hindu by Kalaiyasaran A. which presents a bit of contradictory view. Btw whenever I try & attach a link the comment doesn't get posted, Sorry for that. But, please do check the article out 🙏🙏
Dear Jaydeep!
Thank you for suggesting us regarding the article!
We appreciate your engagement with the topic covered.
Have a good day!
Thank you so much Pooja mam 🙏 very nice In NEWS Freebie Culture dangerous.
Thank you Mam for taking this topic
Much needed
Subsidies: must be needed and can't live or produce products without it
Freebies: may be needed
Thank Drishti 🙏
Thank you, Ankitaj! We are glad to have a viewer like you.
It will be great if you stay connected to view our other programs as well!
What is the difference between '"freebie" or revadi and "NPA or other Write offs". Only difference is freebie is petty amount to poor and down trodden and "write offs" ,to rich Corporates, who indirectly route money to political parties and politicians
Of course distribution of any goods can be checked, but not "free health, free education, free drinking water" which are constitutionally mandated. Again subsidised electricity and transport to poor and down trodden should be considered a welfare act.
Now who is a "Tax Payer"? Till recently an Income Tax Payer was considered as tax payer which now a days looks farce. Because GST paid by each citizen poor, down trodden, lower middile and middle which category constitute 80 to 90% of population. Even excise duty to petrol products are also lagely shared by the non rich category.
Now the question do the lower category of population get their due pro rata share of GDP, means the fruits of development? A big no is the answer.
So the lower segment be brought up by paying free health, education, and other subsidised services like water, electricity, transport etc.
The current sudden rise of question is clearly understandable to be a BJP sponsored project to prevent Kejriwal to capture India, but will fail, by all means. Politicians and parties must realise that " Voters are Masters" not those to whom votes are cast. It is good if better sense prevail in the initial stage only.
so true. This crony capitalistic govt decreased corporate taxes and calls the welfare products given to poor public a freebie. Propagandist govt
Subsidies aren't freebies. They should not be. They are different from freebies. Subsidy could be granted to enhance welfare and production in a certain way. But, freebies are a medium to gain political support .
Thank you ma'am 😊
Subsidies, we get after spending or producing or contributing in the economy, it is a help to bear the cost, while freebies have no role in the Development.
it is necessity of poor. Those free laptops helped poor people to study online in COVID
Thank you ma'am 😊
Namaste mam 🙏🏻
Thank you ma'am
Most welcome 😊
Thanks you so much ma'am
Keep watching Sumit!
Thank u so much ma'am 💓💓❤️
Nice
Thnq mam..
Good
Thank you mam
Most welcome 😊
Mam please eat well...U got slim...
How freebies can help lesser developed state???
Dear aspirant,
Glad you asked the question for better enlightenment.
Well, let's take a state which has a relatively lower level of development but it has a larger share of the population suffering from poverty, now in that case, such kind of freebies become need based
Hence, it becomes essential to provide the people with such subsidies for their own upliftment.
The freebies can serve as welfare in such states.
For better and more knowledge on the topic, you can look at the article given below:
www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/are-freebies-affecting-the-economic-growth-of-india/article65363024.ece
Your interest and engagement with the channel is highly valued and necessary for our upcoming segments.
Thank you.
Regards,
Team Drishti IAS.
Why freebies are dangerous? If corruption isn't.
Becoz freebies leads to rise in prices
If someone is not paying the money then someone else has to
If poor are not paying than middle class has to bear this burden
And middle class are back bone of the country i dont think so it's good for long term see what happened to Sri Lanka becoz of freebies
There is 0% chance of recession in India( Bloomberg report) but freebie culture can change everything
Please spread this message
Giving jobs is better than giving free electricity,water etc
@@prabuddhatripathi you aren't read my comment properly, read it again. I am asking about corruption 😊😊
@@Noah-un3os that's the actual point is
Your whiteboard display is not bright as "Drishti IAS hindi channel". Your display seems too dark. Pls note my point and update it ASAP
Hi, Thank you for your valuable feedback, we will forward it to the concerned team.
I think this freebie is destroy punjab in next 5 years
Thanks Ma'am 🙏